From Daily Fantasy to Sports Betting: How One Clause in a 2006 Law Built DraftKings and FanDuel

The law that cut online poker off from American banks contains a three-part exclusion for fantasy sports. The words 'skill game' are not in it. DraftKings and FanDuel were built on that clause, nearly lost New York over it, and were standing in the right place when sports betting opened in 2018.

Published 2025-11-17. Updated 2026-11-16.

The clause that daily fantasy sports was built on is one sentence in the Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act of 2006, at 31 U.S.C. 5362(1)(E)(ix), and it does not contain the words "skill game." It says that a "bet or wager" does not include a fantasy contest that meets three conditions. Everything DraftKings and FanDuel became, including the two largest sportsbooks in the country, started as an argument about those three conditions.

In 60 seconds

The 2006 law that restricted payments for online gambling excluded fantasy contests with prizes fixed in advance, outcomes reflecting skill across multiple real events, and no result resting on a single game or a single athlete's single performance. FanDuel launched in 2009 and DraftKings in 2012 with contests that lasted a day. New York's attorney general ordered both to stop on November 10, 2015; New York legalized the contests by statute on August 3, 2016. The Supreme Court struck down the federal sports betting ban on May 14, 2018, and DraftKings launched a New Jersey sportsbook that August. In 2025 American sportsbooks won nearly $17 billion.

01

What the 2006 clause says

The act did not ban gambling. It restricted the payment system from handling unlawful internet wagers, and then defined what a wager was not. A fantasy contest falls outside the definition if all prizes "are established and made known to the participants in advance" and are not set by the number of entrants or the fees they pay; if winning outcomes "reflect the relative knowledge and skill of the participants" and are determined mostly by statistics from "multiple real-world sporting or other events"; and if no outcome is based on the score or point spread of a single team, or solely on one athlete's performance in one event.

The usual story is that Congress wrote this to protect season-long office leagues. A 2016 Congressional Research Service report on fantasy sports says the intent is unclear. An earlier version of this page added that season-long fantasy was "already a $15 billion a year industry" in 2006; we found no source for that and have removed it.

One thing the clause never did was make a contest legal under state law. It took fantasy sports out of one federal statute, and the fight that followed was fought in the states.

02

A contest that ends tonight

FanDuel launched on July 21, 2009, spun out of a Scottish prediction-market company called Hubdub and based in New York. DraftKings followed from Boston in February 2012. Their insight was that nothing in the three conditions requires a season. Draft a lineup this afternoon, score it on tonight's games, pay the winners by midnight: multiple athletes, multiple events, prizes posted in advance.

By September 2015 each company was valued at more than $1 billion and between them they held about 95% of the market, by Wikipedia's summary of the coverage. The size of that market is routinely overstated. The "$4 billion industry" this page once cited is in the range of trade estimates for what players paid in entry fees that year, not for what the companies kept. The Congressional Research Service put the industry's net revenue for 2014 at $86 million.

03

New York, 2015 to 2022

On November 10, 2015 New York's attorney general, Eric Schneiderman, sent both companies cease-and-desist letters, and his office's release the next day demanded that they "immediately stop accepting wagers inside New York." The argument was that the contests were gambling under state law. The release also said the "vast majority of winnings" went to roughly the top one percent of players.

It is often said that the federal government stayed out of it. The same Congressional Research Service report notes that a federal grand jury in Tampa was reported to be investigating daily fantasy operators at the time, so that is more than we can say.

What followed took seven years to finish. Lawsuits followed within days. In March 2016 the companies agreed to stop paid contests in New York while the legislature considered a bill. On August 3, 2016 the governor signed Chapter 237 of the Laws of 2016, which added an article on "Interactive Fantasy Sports" to the state's racing and wagering law. The false-advertising claims were settled separately that October, reportedly for $6 million from each company. And the statute itself was challenged as a violation of the state constitution's ban on gambling until March 22, 2022, when New York's Court of Appeals upheld it, 4 to 3, in White v. Cuomo.

Other states wrote laws of their own. By early 2018, 19 had fantasy sports statutes, by the National Conference of State Legislatures' count as cited by the Tax Foundation; the operators were taking entries in about 41. The "40 states had legalized it" in the earlier version of this page ran those two numbers together.

04

The merger that did not happen, and the ruling that did

The two companies then agreed to merge. The Federal Trade Commission, with California and the District of Columbia, sued to block the deal on June 19, 2017, saying the combined firm would control "more than 90 percent of the U.S. market for paid daily fantasy sports contests." They abandoned it the following month.

Ten months later the ground moved. On May 14, 2018, in Murphy v. NCAA, the Supreme Court held that the federal law barring states from authorizing sports betting "violates the anticommandeering rule." The decision legalized nothing by itself. It let each state decide.

The two fantasy companies had what a new sportsbook needs: a large base of verified American customers with funded accounts. DraftKings launched its New Jersey sportsbook on August 1, 2018. FanDuel agreed that May to be bought by Paddy Power Betfair and opened in New Jersey that summer; sources give different dates for its first bet. Our DraftKings and FanDuel post picks up from there.

05

Where it stands

Sports betting is now the main business. The American Gaming Association reported that sportsbooks won nearly $17 billion in 2025 on $166.9 billion wagered, up 22.8% on the year, as carried by CDC Gaming. We have no reliable figure for daily fantasy revenue in 2026 and have removed the one this page used to give.

The legal argument has not gone away, which is the part the standard history leaves out. That history ends in 2018 with the loophole made irrelevant. On July 3, 2025 California's attorney general issued Opinion No. 23-1001, concluding that state law "prohibits the operation of daily fantasy sports games" and that they "constitute wagering on sports in violation of Penal Code section 337a." The opinion is advisory, and trade press reported that the operators kept serving California. From 2023 several states also went after pick'em contests, in which a player bets against the house on whether athletes go over or under a statistic; by Wikipedia's account, PrizePicks agreed in February 2024 to stop those contests in New York and pay $15 million.

Read the three conditions again with pick'em in mind. One athlete, one statistic, one game is close to exactly what the third condition excludes. The clause that built the industry is still the one deciding what it may sell.

If you would rather bet on a game than a lineup, our sports betting guide explains the price you pay for it, and our Black Friday post covers what the same 2006 law did to online poker.

What was checked, and when. The statutory text is 31 U.S.C. 5362(1)(E)(ix), read at Cornell's Legal Information Institute. The New York attorney general's release is dated November 11, 2015; the fantasy sports statute is Article 14 of New York's Racing, Pari-Mutuel Wagering and Breeding Law, as posted by the state senate. The merger challenge is the Federal Trade Commission's release of June 19, 2017. Murphy v. NCAA is quoted from the opinion. California's opinion is quoted from the attorney general's published text. All were read on November 16, 2026. Company dates, valuations, the March 2016 standstill, the 2022 ruling, the abandoned merger, the Paddy Power Betfair deal and the PrizePicks settlement are from Wikipedia's articles and the reports they cite, a secondary source. The 2014 revenue figure and the Tampa grand jury are from Congressional Research Service report R44398. The count of 19 state statutes, the $6 million settlements and the 2025 sports betting figures reached us through search summaries and trade press, not the original documents. Removed on November 16 because nothing supports them: a $15 billion season-long industry in 2006, a $4 billion industry in 2015 described as revenue, a claim that New York was the largest market, a 2026 fantasy revenue figure, and a statement that the Justice Department was not involved. Not verified: which states prohibit paid fantasy contests in 2026, and the date of FanDuel's first legal sports bet. If gambling has stopped being a cost you set in advance, 1-800-GAMBLER is free and confidential.

Last updated November 16, 2026

Topics

  • dfs
  • fantasy-sports
  • sports-betting
  • history

Related guides

More casino guides